Skip to main content

The Debate of the Decade: Should Doctors Amputate Healthy Limbs?

Body Integrity Identity Disorder (BIID) has sparked controversy in the medical field for the past decade. When I found out about this disorder, I thought it logical to bring the issue on this blog. 
____________________________ 

So what is BIID?


Body Integrity Identity Disorder, also known as Amputee Identity Disorder, is a psychological disorder in which a person has a strong desire to be an amputee. In simple words, BIID is a disorder that causes those who have it to believe a part of their body does not belong to them. That gives them the desire to amputate that perfectly healthy limb. 

The dangerous side of the issue is that people with BIID may take drastic measures to amputate their unwanted limb. And let's just say it can get unreservedly brutal. People raise up the solution as to whether doctors should perform the amputation in a safe and less brutal environment. However, any surgeon who performs an amputation on a healthy limb can undoubtedly put his/her license at risk. In 2000, a British surgeon named Robert Smith amputated perfectly healthy limbs of two men. Smith's operation had caused serious upheaval. As a result, in 2012, no doctor in Britain was allowed to amputate healthy limbs.1

But the debate still remains today: should doctors amputate healthy limbs? Is it ethical? What
This topic is open for a healthy debate; so comment down below and tell me what you think.

*P.S. if you like these kind of posts, please let me know so I can publish more posts like this*

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

1 Month at the University of Pennsylvania Update + Important Announcement!!

In light of the current college application season, I will be editing college essays for free (no strings attached!). If you want me to edit your essays, please let me know in the comment section below, and I'll reach out to you as to where to send your essays. Do not use the 'Contact' tab on the home page to contact me because it is currently not working. Like I said before, the best way to contact me is by commenting on this post.  I am a current freshman at the University of Pennsylvania (completely done with my college applications), and all essays will be deleted from my device after I finish editing them. Therefore, you do not need to worry about whether or not your essays will be plagiarized or used without your consent. I sincerely want to help you as much as I possibly could as you work on your college applications.  All the best! -Kristine __________________________________________________________________________________ Wow! I can't believe it has already bee

BIG CHANGES

Hey guys! Welcome back! It's been quite a while since I last posted on this blog, and I'm quite sorry about that. My schedule is QUITE busy. School got in the way and other extracurriculars. The volleyball season in my school started last week, and volleyball practice happens to occur EVERY SINGLE DAY!  On top of everything, I STARTED A NEW BLOG! It's not another pre-med blog -- it's a photography blog.  Check out my blog: Beyond the Lens. (Click on the link below to view my blog). I'm so excited about all the things I have in store for the blog. Beyond the Lens Do not worry guys! I haven't given up on you! I will still continue to publish posts on this blog, but not as frequently. I plan to publish a post once or twice a month -- so stay tuned! There's another thing I have to tell you guys... I plan to completely update this blog! My desire is to change the layout and the theme, and make this blog look AMAZING! This will happen in a few

Where Am I Heading to College? (It's been a long time)

Hey guys!!! It's been quite a while since I last posted on this blog, and quite a lot has changed since then. The current state of the US and the world, with the coronavirus and the brutal death of George Floyd, is crazy. I hope you all stay safe and don't forget to wear a mask! I have been so inconsistent in posting on this blog that many of you have little to no idea where I am going to college. If you want to hear more about my extraordinarily unique college application and decision experience, please let me know! Anyhow, I know all of you have been waiting for where I plan to attend college this year. After all, I did not even tell you the schools I applied to... I am glad to say that I will be attending the University of Pennsylvania this fall, majoring in biology and on the pre-med track (obviously!). I am beyond blessed and grateful for this opportunity God has given me. I cannot wait to spend my next four years at Penn! As for this blog, I am no longer a 'pre